Since 1985, Fahey Realtors agents have been earning―and keeping―our clients’ trust with an unwavering commitment to white-glove service, expertise, and integrity, combining real estate expertise with unrivaled market knowledge and neighborhood fluency.

With more than 37 years of experience, we’ve learned that your real estate decisions are personal and emotional. We understand that buying or selling your home is one of the most significant milestones of your life. With this in mind, we created our full-service agency and continue to bring expertise coupled with unparalleled personal attention to help you make smart, informed decisions.

Whether it’s your first town home, a newly constructed estate, or an undeveloped property, we continually strive to give you the ultimate client experience at our real estate agency located in Bernardsville, NJ. Regardless of your price range, we are devoted to understanding your needs and delivering the customized service you deserve. We are proud to say that many of our clients inevitably become friends.

Fahey Realtors was founded in November 1985 by Angela Fahey. The original office was located in Bedminster and moved to 61 Claremont Road in Bernardsville in 2000. Angela’s daughter, Carolyn Fahey, joined the company in 2003 and became Broker of Record in 2014.

At Fahey Realtors our five Core Values are more than just words, they’re a way of life. We know that companies with a strong culture and a higher purpose perform better in the long run. As we continue to grow, we strive to ensure that our culture remains alive and well.

The following values we hold as truths for our clients, partners, and each other as members of the Fahey Realtors team.

    1. Provide real estate expertise
    2. Deliver personalized white glove service
    3. Impart unrivaled market knowledge
    4. Exemplify trust, integrity, and commitment
    5. Produce results

Carolyn is the ultimate professional.  She truly cares about her clients, is efficient, calm and knowledgeable; and is a pleasure to work with. We have the highest regard for her and recommend her wholeheartedly.

Markie and Peter Burke, September 2020

Carolyn Fahey is truly an exceptional agent…caring, diligent, efficient and at the very top of the profession. Upon meeting Carolyn, I instantly felt as though my prayers were answered. She listened to my needs and delivered the best property advice and marketing strategy to sell my family’s home. Carolyn is very kind, easy to talk to, good at listening, easily available, and always quick at returning  calls or to respond to my questions. Above all, Carolyn and Team Fahey left no stone unturned and sold my family home.

Michele DeMaio Brady, April 2020

Carolyn assisted us with our new home purchase and was a pleasure to work with. She is knowledgeable, highly professional and was always accessible to answer our many questions, quick to respond and to facilitate any problems. She was always pleasant, so easy to work with and we felt we were in “excellent hands” from start to finish with Carolyn’s expertise. We would most definitely refer her to family and friends for any type of real estate need. We love our new home but if we did have to move in the future, Carolyn would be our “go to” agent for sure!
Nick and Donna Taro, April 2020

It was an absolute pleasure working with Carolyn and Nan at Fahey Realtors and the experience far exceeded all of our expectations. They worked tirelessly on both the sale of our Maplewood home along with the purchase of our new home in Far Hills. They were knowledgable, efficient, professional, personable, and diligent in making sure both transactions were successful in meeting our expectations. Their passion for their profession is evident and the ease with which they handle intricate circumstances is admirable. Carolyn and Nan did everything they promised they would do, all the while treating us like family. They went above and beyond. We highly recommend them.

Josephine and Tim Isgro, June 2018

Unparalleled Personal Attention

Regardless of your price range, our “boutique” real estate agency takes a thoughtful, customized approach to marketing your home while preserving your privacy. Our owners are personally involved with all client relationships and the entire Fahey team of associates is committed to understanding your needs and delivering the ultimate client experience.


Evaluation of your property at no cost – our owners, with over 46 years of combined experience, will focus on ways to make your home or land most presentable. We’ll provide advice concerning market climate, market history in the area, timing and competitive pricing.

Best-in-Class Marketing

Aggressive advertising, Open House showings and Marketing materials including internet-based marketing and virtual tours.

Multiple Listing Service

Draws upon a network of thousands of realtors to help sell your property. Four out of five homes are sold through the Multiple Listing Service (MLS).

Carolyn is one of the best realtors we have ever worked with. She was detailed oriented and was able to follow through on every request we had. We cannot say enough good things about her and the purchase of our house.

Carolyn proved us what a difference an excellent realtor can make. We were amazed and very impressed to see how quickly Carolyn was able to show us houses that were a great fit for us. She clearly knows the market extremely well and understands very quickly what her clients are looking for. Carolyn provided us with a wealth of information and expert advise before and during our search process and guided us expertly through the purchasing and closing process. Every step of the way Carolyn and her team have gone above and beyond and we would highly recommend her to anyone as a best in class realtor.

In preparing to sell our house, I interviewed some of the top firms/agents in the area. I decided to go with Carolyn because she was extremely prepared and enthusiastic, she had relationships with builders, and she had a great knowledge of the area. It turned out that I definitely made the right choice. Because I currently live out of the state, Carolyn was really helpful in coordinating work to be done on the house and researching some zoning issues prior to listing the house. Through her experience she has trustworthy vendors for any type of work, and this was a huge help in easing the burden on me as she helped to coordinate that work. She was able to show builders the house first to gauge interest, and then she aggressively finished the marketing work and got the house listed much more quickly than I thought could happen. Carolyn kept me up-to-date and communicated often throughout the process. We had two offers very quickly and Carolyn brought the highest paying buyer to the table herself. She coordinated with the buyer and lawyers very well, gave me great advice, and we closed without a hitch. Carolyn has the great combination of being both extremely competent and very personable which led to a very successful sale and overall experience, and I could not recommend her more highly.

When my husband and I were toying around with the idea of opening a new business, a friend recommended that we contact Carolyn to explore properties in the Pluckemin area. I contacted her in the late afternoon and she immediately responded with appointments to view relevant properties the next morning. Aside from finding our dream property, Carolyn negotiated on our behalf and arranged a great deal for us, but she didn’t stop there. . . she actually reached out to other local businesswomen and men who offer services and products complimentary to ours, made introductions and helped get our business off of the ground. Aside from being pleasant, prompt and professional at all times, Carolyn was a true advocate for our business and vision. I can’t recommend her highly enough.

While we came across Carolyn arbitrarily visiting a listing, we knew immediately after a single viewing that she was a serious agent. We decided to work with her on our next home search. We bought our next home and now have sold our Clinton Township home through her. Her knowledge of the product, the comps, and all the details that go into a premiere listing is second to none. What you will get with Carolyn and her team is professionalism, confidence and commitment to your sale. Their marketing approach and materials were first rate. You will find their preparedness and candor quite refreshing. Bottom line: we went on the market in mid spring and closed in the summer. We sold at a price point we were pleased with.

I recently moved which is normally torturous, but I had the pleasure of working with Carolyn Fahey of Fahey Realtors in Bernardsville, who made the entire process not only easy but pleasant. If you’re thinking about a move, I highly recommend you talk to Carolyn. Her expertise, professionalism and caring, as well as that of her entire team, are second to none and helped minimize my stress. I cannot recommend Carolyn and Fahey Realtors highly enough.

Carolyn and her team were in a word fantastic. Exceptionally professional, knowledgeable, completely engaged and on top of her game. We had a complicated cross country move and a unique transaction. She was relentless in her pursuit of our interests and was the key negotiator to make sure this deal got done. Everyone on both sides was ecstatic- she’s the best realtor we’ve worked with in 6 transactions all over the country!

Carolyn is an outstanding professional who is great to work with. She knows the market, has a lot of experience and brings a very effective style is working on the buy and sell sides. We have worked on a number of transactions and they have all gone very well. Carolyn does her homework, sets appropriate expectations and keeps her client interests first.

Carolyn is a terrific asset for anyone in the market for a new home. She is experienced, extremely knowledgeable and truly operates with only her client’s best interest in mind.

Carolyn is amazing–she is a real go getter who is smart and business savvy. I wouldn’t use any other realtor! She went out of her way to assess where to market our home, and to locate buyers in New York City who were interested in moving to the suburbs. She sold our house within 2 weeks for more than our asking price. Need we say more?!!

Carolyn helped me sell my condo located in a section of the hills in bedminster nj. She was very personable and pleasant to work with. She did a great job staging, showing, and selling my house very quickly. I would highly recommend her to anyone who needs to buy or sell a home.